It’s Pi Day, celebrated worldwide on March 14th (3.14, get it?). Pi Day isn’t just for mathematicians; it’s a day that brings people together over the universal love for pie, whether sweet or savory.
And what better way to celebrate than by supporting our local bakeries and pie shops?
Many local spots are celebrating with discounts, buy-one-get-one deals, or special Pi Day flavors. It’s a great opportunity to try something new or stick with a beloved classic.
Mr. Dye’s Pies at 3rd Street Market Hall
📍 275 W. Wisconsin Ave. | 📞 (414) 759-4992 | 🌐 3rdstmarkethall.com/mrdyespies
For a slice of homemade, grandma-worthy goodness, head to Mr. Dye’s Pies inside 3rd Street Market Hall. Their menu includes everything from sweet potato and pecan pies to the fun Purple Monster and peanut butter-filled Carver Pie.New this year—savory pasties! You can walk in for a slice or pre-order to make sure you don’t miss out. While you’re there, let the kids burn off some energy with arcade games and playtime in the market hall.
The Elegant Farmer – Mukwonago
📍 1545 Main St. (Hwy ES & J), Mukwonago | 📞 (262) 363-6770 | 🌐 elegantfarmer.com
Famous for its pies baked in a paper bag, The Elegant Farmer is offering a $3.14 discount on their mini apple pies(regularly $9.99) for Pi Day! They also have a variety of flavors like caramel apple, blueberry apple, peachy apple, and rhubarb apple. This deal runs through March 14th, so don’t miss out!
🕘 Hours: 9 a.m. – 6 p.m. daily
Rocket Baby Bakery – Wauwatosa
📍 6822 W. North Ave., Wauwatosa | 📞 (414) 502-7323 | 🌐 rocketbabybakery.com
For those craving something a bit different, Rocket Baby Bakery is serving up dark chocolate pecan pie, banana caramel cream pie, and apple lattice pie for Pi Day. Be sure to pre-order by March 12 to secure your slice of heaven.
🕘 Hours:
- Store: 7 a.m. – 2 p.m. daily
- Bakery pickup window: 8 a.m. – 2 p.m. daily
Blue’s Egg – Milwaukee
📍 317 N. 76th St., Milwaukee | 📞 (414) 299-3180 | 🌐 bluesegg.com
From now through Saturday, March 15, Blue’s Egg, Story Hill BKC, and Maxie’s Southern Comfort are offering Buy One, Get One Half Off on their pies! Plus, enjoy $3.14 off any whole pie from Blue’s Bakery inside Blue’s Egg.
Flavors include:
🍀 Irish Cream (seasonal & dreamy)
🍫 French Silk
🍏 Dutch Apple
🧂 Salted Brown Butter
🍋 Key Lime
🥃 Bourbon Pecan
Honeypie Cafe
In our humble opinion, there’s not a better place for pie in Milwaukee than Bay View’s quirky and homey Honeypie Cafe. With last year’s crowd in mind, they’re making sure they’re fully stocked with their delicious pies. Pre-ordering your whole pie is highly recommended to secure favorites like Milwaukee Mud Pie, Salted Wisconsin Honey Pie, Lemon Supreme, and Chocolate Silk Pie.
🕘 Hours: 8 a.m. – 9 p.m. daily
Pre-ordering your whole pie is recommended to avoid missing out on their tastiest selection. Favorites include Milwaukee Mud Pie, Salted Wisconsin Honey Pie, Lemon Supreme, and Chocolate Silk Pie.
National Bakery & Deli
📍 Locations in Brookfield, Greendale, and Milwaukee | 📞 Varies by location | 🌐 nationalbakery.com
National Bakery & Deli is offering a classic lineup of pies, including: banana cream, cherry, apple, chocolate cream, Dutch apple, and strawberry cream. Whether you’re a pie purist or feeling adventurous, this is a great place to grab a slice.
Mor Bakehouse
📍 5504 W. State St. | 📞 (414) 249-3316 | 🌐 morfoodsmke.com
If someone in your house is gluten-free, this is for you! This certified gluten-free bakery is offering apple and pecan pie slices for pre-order, ready for pick-up at 3 p.m. on Pi Day! If you’re in the neighborhood between 11 a.m. and 5:30 p.m., stop by to browse their selection of fresh, gluten-free treats.
Lakefront Brewery
📍 1872 N. Commerce St. | 📞 (414) 372-8800 | 🌐 lakefrontbrewery.com
Lakefront Brewery has made Pi Day a fun tradition! Since it falls on a Friday this year, they’ll be offering Chocolate Cream Pie slices all day long—but grab yours early before they sell out. Make an early reservation for the Friday fish fry at this craft brewery. Your kids will love the polka music, dancing, and delicious food. Our readers highly recommend it!
Matilda Bakehouse
📍 6874 N. Santa Monica Blvd., Fox Point | 📞 (414) 364-8869 | 🌐 matildabakehouse.com
If you’re on the North Shore, Matilda Bakehouse has a delicious Pi Day lineup available for pre-order, including Salted Caramel Apple, French Silk, and Derby Pie (loaded with pecans and chocolate chips). A limited number of slices will also be available in-store on March 14th.
Pi Day Events
Mathnasium Pie Day Celebrations (Free!)
Celebrate Pi Day with Mathnasium! On Friday, March 14, from 4-6 PM, multiple Mathnasium locations across the Milwaukee area are hosting free, family-friendly Pi Day celebrations. Kids ages 5-17 can enjoy math challenges, sweet treats, and a chance to win prizes. Plus, there’s a special discount available through March 31. Check our Events Calendar for full details and locations!
Related Posts:
Calie Herbst, Editor-in-Chief of Milwaukee With Kids, has spent over a decade combining her experiences as a parent of three to create a hub for Milwaukee’s family adventures.
Her decade-long teaching career in Milwaukee Public Schools and academic background, including a Master’s in Teaching from Marquette University and dual B.A.s in Sociology and Spanish from the University of Wisconsin – Madison, fuel her passion for inclusive and engaging family content.
Calie is also a recognized voice in local media, contributing to WISN Channel 12 News, WTMJ Wisconsin Morning News, Fox 6’s Real Milwaukee, and B93.3.
Discover more about Calie’s journey and editorial approach on her About Page and Editorial Policy Page.
